Thursday, December 18, 2008

Fantasy Gone Wrong - Martin Greenberg & Brittiany Koren


2006; 16 stories; 309 pages. Genre : Fantasy. Overall Rating : B.
.
Hey, is that a cool bookcover or what?! Sixteen authors were asked to write tales with humor, irony, and unexpected twists. At an average length of 19 pages, things like depth and development of characters are forgivably non-existent. As with any anthology, some stories were excellent; others were so-so.
.
My only gripe is with the last one ("Is This Real Enough?"), and that's only because of its sloppy spell-checking. "Deity" was repeatedly spelled d-i-e-t-y, and the name of one of the characters, Mirri, was occasionally spelled with only one "R". My normal review format doesn't work well with anthologies, so here's six of the stories that I liked.
.
01. Goblin Lullaby. It's elves and mankind versus witches and goblins, but this one's told from a goblin nursemaid's perspective. My personal favorite in the book.
.
02. The Rose, The Farmboy, and the Gnome. Jed (the farmboy) owes 1000 gold pieces to the pixie underworld; or else Uncle Gotti and his femme fatale daughters are going to start slicing off various parts of his body. A nice, unexpected ending.
.
03. New Yorke Snowe. A village whore (yes, there are adult themes and cussing in these stories), finds that a magic unicorn is inexplicably tagging along with her, which is interfering with her livelihood. Some nice twists, and a non-stereotypical stepmother.
.
04. The Hero of Killorglin. A Tolkienish doggy faery tale. Short on the humor; long on the beauty.
.
05. Finder's Keeper. Kinda like the Sorcerer's Apprentice segment in Fantasia, save that here it's the mage's pet wyrm and an animated spell book.
.
06. Food Fight. A guy can hear food talking to him. The opening line is "My coffee keeps insulting me". Hilariously witty, although the storyline lags a bit.

2 comments:

Christina said...

Thanks for the review. I definitely look forward to reading it now.

hamilcar barca said...

yep, it will be interesting to see which ones turn out to be your favorites. everyone's reading tastes are different.

i'm also interested in seeing how this compartes with the other fantasy anthology books you've read. there seem to be a slew of anthology books compiled by Martin Greenberg. i saw one with "forests" as the unifying theme; another with "future times" as the common thread.

the used-bookstore i go to has rows upon rows of fantasy anthology books. so if i get into this genre in 2009, i won't lack for books to choose from.